These are costume sewing patterns, not sewing machines, so I’m comparing project choices rather than machine features. For a child who wants several dress-up options, Simplicity 8726 offers five designs and the broadest language support. For two coordinated girls’ looks, McCall’s M6817 in children’s sizes pairs a Scottish princess with a gothic vampire. Adults who want those same two themes can choose the women’s M6817, which covers sizes Small through Extra Large.
Get art and craft supplies delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The main tradeoff is straightforward: more costume options do not necessarily mean an easier sewing project. All three patterns are paper-based and call for sewing skills beyond the absolute beginner level, while fabric and other supplies are separate purchases. I rank these picks by how well their age range, costume variety, and stated skill level fit common Halloween sewing plans—not by any claim that one is a sewing machine.
Key Takeaways
- Simplicity 8726 is the most versatile children’s choice, with five costumes for sizes 3–8 and instructions in English, Spanish, and French.
- McCall’s M6817 for girls is the more focused choice for two gothic or storybook looks, covering children’s sizes 3–8 with English and Spanish instructions.
- McCall’s M6817 for women offers the adult option in this lineup, with sizes Small through Extra Large and the same two costume themes.
- All three are physical paper patterns, not sewing machines; none includes fabric or sewing supplies according to the provided product details.
- Each pattern is aimed at average or above-average skills, so absolute beginners may need help before cutting fabric.
| Simplicity 8726 DIY Halloween Costume Sewing Pattern for Kids, Sizes 3–8 |  | Best for costume variety | Brand: Simplicity | Model number: US8726A | Format: Physical paper pattern | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| McCall’s M6817 Girl’s Scottish Princess and Vampire Costume Sewing Pattern, Sizes 3–8 |  | Best for a coordinated girls’ costume theme | Brand: McCall’s | Pattern number: M6817 | Format: Paper pattern | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| McCall’s M6817 Women’s Scottish Princess and Vampire Halloween Costume Sewing Pattern |  | Best for adult costumes | Brand: McCall’s | Model number: M6817 | Format: Paper pattern | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Halloween costume sewing machine | Brand | Format | Costume designs | Size range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simplicity 8726 DIY Halloween | Simplicity | Physical paper pattern | Bat man, witch, clown, vampire, and cat | Children’s sizes 3–8 |
| McCall’s M6817 Girl’s Scottish | McCall’s | Paper pattern | Scottish princess and gothic vampire | Sizes 3–4, 5–6, and 7–8 |
| McCall’s M6817 Women’s Scottis | McCall’s | Paper pattern | Scottish princess and gothic vampire | Women’s Small through Extra Large |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Simplicity 8726 DIY Halloween Costume Sewing Pattern for Kids, Sizes 3–8
Simplicity 8726 is my most flexible pick for children because it gives a household five costume directions—bat man, witch, clown, vampire, and cat—rather than restricting the project to one paired theme. That variety is valuable when a child changes their mind, siblings want different looks, or the same pattern may be used for dress-up beyond Halloween. Its child sizing runs from 3 to 8, matching the children’s McCall’s option at the broadest level while offering three more costume designs.
The language coverage also sets it apart: instructions are listed in English, Spanish, and French, whereas both McCall’s patterns list English and Spanish. That may make this a better household fit when French instructions are useful. The tradeoff is that the product information does not describe a lower skill requirement than the other two picks; it is still a paper sewing pattern, not a ready-made costume or a machine. Buyers need to provide fabric and supplies, and should be comfortable working from templates and instructions.
Compared with the girls’ McCall’s M6817, Simplicity gives up the specific Scottish-princess pairing but gains broader character choice. Compared with the women’s M6817, it is clearly for children rather than adults. I’d put it first for families who value options over a tightly matched princess-and-vampire theme, but not for anyone seeking adult sizing or a clearly beginner-oriented project.
Pros:- Five costume designs provide more theme choice than either McCall’s pattern.
- Covers children’s sizes 3–8.
- Instructions are listed in English, Spanish, and French.
- Templates and sizing guidance support planning a handmade costume.
Cons:- Paper pattern only; fabric and sewing supplies are separate.
- Limited to child sizing, with no adult size range listed.
- The supplied details do not position it as a beginner-level pattern.
Best for: Families sewing for children in sizes 3–8 who want several costume themes and may use the pattern for Halloween and dress-up play.
Not ideal for: Adults, children outside the listed size range, and absolute beginners looking for a pattern explicitly described as easy.
- Brand:Simplicity
- Model number:US8726A
- Format:Physical paper pattern
- Costume designs:Bat man, witch, clown, vampire, and cat
- Size range:Children’s sizes 3–8
- Instruction languages:English, Spanish, and French
- Suggested uses:Halloween costumes, dress-up, and play time
- Manufacturer:CSS Industries, Inc.
Our verdict“I’d choose Simplicity 8726 when costume variety for a child matters more than a specific princess-and-vampire pairing.”
McCall’s M6817 Girl’s Scottish Princess and Vampire Costume Sewing Pattern, Sizes 3–8
This children’s McCall’s pattern is the focused alternative to Simplicity’s five-character assortment. It supplies two contrasting looks—a Scottish princess and a gothic vampire—for girls in sizes 3–4, 5–6, and 7–8. That pairing suits a buyer who already knows the desired storybook or gothic direction, or who wants two different costume moods available from one packet. It does not match Simplicity for sheer variety, but the narrower theme makes the choice more direct.
Its English and Spanish instructions match the women’s McCall’s version, while the paper format keeps it in the same category as all three products here. The pattern includes templates, instructions, and sizing guides, but the stated skill level is average or above average. I would not treat the two costume designs as evidence that the sewing itself is simple. Fabric and supplies are not included in the supplied product details, so the pattern is only one part of the project plan.
Compared with the adult M6817, this listing is the clear choice when the wearer is a child; the women’s pattern covers Small through Extra Large instead. Compared with Simplicity 8726, it trades five distinct costumes and French instructions for the specific princess-and-vampire pair. I’d rank it second because it is less adaptable across costume themes than Simplicity, while still being a strong fit for the intended child size range and aesthetic.
Pros:- Includes two distinct girls’ costume designs in one pattern.
- Provides templates, instructions, and sizing guides.
- Covers child sizes 3–8 in grouped size ranges.
- Instructions are listed in English and Spanish.
Cons:- Limited to children’s sizes 3–8.
- Requires average or above-average sewing skill.
- Offers fewer costume themes and fewer instruction languages than Simplicity 8726.
Best for: Sewists making a Scottish-princess or gothic-vampire costume for a girl in sizes 3–8, especially when English or Spanish instructions suit the household.
Not ideal for: Families seeking many different costume themes, adults needing a pattern, or new sewists wanting an explicitly easy project.
- Brand:McCall’s
- Pattern number:M6817
- Format:Paper pattern
- Costume designs:Scottish princess and gothic vampire
- Size range:Sizes 3–4, 5–6, and 7–8
- Skill level:Average to above average
- Instruction languages:English and Spanish
- Included:Templates, instructions, and sizing guides
Our verdict“I’d pick the girls’ M6817 over Simplicity when the princess-and-vampire theme matters more than having five costume options.”
McCall’s M6817 Women’s Scottish Princess and Vampire Halloween Costume Sewing Pattern
The women’s M6817 is the only adult-size option in this comparison, making it the natural choice when a grown-up wants to sew rather than buy a ready-made costume. It contains two sharply different designs—a Scottish princess and a gothic vampire—and covers Women’s Small through Extra Large. That separates it from the girls’ M6817, which uses the same broad costume concept but is sized for children 3–8. Before choosing, buyers should check the pattern’s sizing guide rather than assuming garment sizes map directly to everyday clothing sizes.
The two-design format is a useful middle ground: it offers more than a single look without the wider character selection of Simplicity 8726. English and Spanish instructions match the girls’ McCall’s version, but not Simplicity’s French option. The pattern is described for average to above-average sewing skills, so I would not place it ahead of the others for a novice simply because it is an adult pattern. Its paper pieces also need careful storage to avoid creasing or damage.
This is the best match for adults who want one of these particular costume styles, not a general-purpose Halloween pattern collection or sewing machine. Compared with the children’s McCall’s version, the meaningful advantage is adult sizing; compared with Simplicity, the tradeoff is two designs instead of five. I rank it third only because its use case is narrower, not because it is a weaker fit for an adult wearer.
Pros:- Provides two adult costume designs in one packet.
- Covers women’s sizes Small through Extra Large.
- Includes templates, instructions, and sizing guidance.
- Instructions are listed in English and Spanish.
Cons:- Requires average to above-average sewing skills.
- Paper pattern pieces can be damaged if stored or handled carelessly.
- Offers two designs, fewer than the five in Simplicity 8726.
Best for: Adults sewing a Scottish-princess or gothic-vampire costume in women’s sizes Small through Extra Large.
Not ideal for: Children, buyers wanting a wide range of character themes, or beginners who need a pattern identified as easy.
- Brand:McCall’s
- Model number:M6817
- Format:Paper pattern
- Costume designs:Scottish princess and gothic vampire
- Size range:Women’s Small through Extra Large
- Skill level:Average to above average
- Instruction languages:English and Spanish
- Country of origin:USA
Our verdict“I’d choose the women’s M6817 when adult sizing and its princess-or-vampire theme matter more than a larger menu of costume ideas.”
How We Picked
I ranked these products around the decisions that matter when sewing a Halloween costume: who the pattern fits, how many designs it supplies, and what skill level it expects. Since the requested topic says “sewing machines” but the supplied products are paper patterns, I’ve made that distinction explicit rather than implying any item is a machine or evaluating machine performance.
Costume choice and age range carry the most weight in this lineup. Simplicity 8726 leads for families who want several kid-friendly themes in one packet. The two McCall’s patterns each provide a Scottish princess and gothic vampire design, but serve different age groups: one covers girls’ sizes 3–8 and the other women’s Small through Extra Large. That makes the sizing distinction more useful than treating the two McCall’s listings as interchangeable.
I also weighed instruction languages and project expectations. Simplicity’s English, Spanish, and French instructions offer the widest language choice. Both McCall’s versions list English and Spanish. All three are paper patterns and are described as suitable for average to above-average sewing skill, so I do not rank any as a beginner-first project. I’ve noted the practical limits—separate fabric and supplies, age-specific sizing, and paper handling—so each recommendation has a clear use case as well as a reason to pass.
| Halloween costume sewing machine | Brand | Model number | Format | Costume designs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Simplicity 8726 DIY Halloween | Simplicity | US8726A | Physical paper pattern | Bat man, witch, clown, vampire, and cat |
| McCall’s M6817 Girl’s Scottish | McCall’s | — | Paper pattern | Scottish princess and gothic vampire |
| McCall’s M6817 Women’s Scottis | McCall’s | M6817 | Paper pattern | Scottish princess and gothic vampire |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Halloween Costume Sewing Machines
I’d start by matching the wearer and the costume idea to the pattern, then check whether the project’s skill expectations and included materials fit the time available. These listings are sewing patterns, so the machine itself is a separate decision.Choose the right wearer size range
Size range is the first filter because two of these listings use the M6817 name but serve different wearers. The girls’ version covers child sizes 3–8, while the women’s version covers Small through Extra Large. Simplicity 8726 also covers child sizes 3–8. I would compare the specific pattern measurements and sizing guide with the intended wearer before cutting, rather than relying only on a familiar clothing size label.
If you are sewing for a child, the girls’ M6817 and Simplicity are the relevant choices. If the wearer is an adult, only the women’s M6817 belongs on the shortlist. A pattern cannot be made suitable simply because its costume theme is appealing; the listed size range needs to match the person wearing it.
Decide between costume variety and a focused theme
Simplicity 8726 offers five character directions, which makes it the most adaptable choice for changing preferences, multiple dress-up ideas, or a household that wants different costumes from one packet. The two McCall’s patterns are more focused: each presents a Scottish princess and gothic vampire. That can be a benefit if those are precisely the looks you want, but it leaves less room to pivot to a witch, cat, clown, or other character from Simplicity’s selection.
I would not treat “more designs” as an automatic win. A focused pair may be easier to choose between when the theme is already settled, while a broader assortment is handy when the costume plan is still open. Pick according to the wearer’s actual preference, not the biggest number of designs on the package.
Be realistic about sewing skill and project time
None of these is described as a beginner pattern. Both McCall’s listings specify average to above-average skill, and the product details for Simplicity do not establish a simpler skill level. If you are new to sewing, expect to spend time reading the instructions, checking the pattern pieces, and learning any unfamiliar techniques before a deadline-driven Halloween project.
A confident sewist may value the chance to make a distinctive costume and adjust details to suit the wearer. A newer sewist may want an experienced helper or a less complex project instead. I would leave time for fitting and construction rather than assuming that a paper pattern turns into a finished costume in one short session.
Remember that a pattern is not a machine or a complete kit
These products are physical paper patterns, not sewing machines. They provide templates and instructions, but the listed descriptions do not include a machine, fabric, or a full set of sewing supplies. Buyers should plan separately for the materials and tools needed to make the costume. The specific machine requirements are not provided here, so I would not infer that one particular machine feature is required for any of these designs.
Paper patterns also need reasonable care. Keep the pieces and instructions together, and avoid storing them where they may be crushed, dampened, or torn. That is especially relevant if you expect to reuse the pattern for another costume or a later dress-up project.
Compare instruction languages and household needs
Simplicity has the widest listed language selection, with English, Spanish, and French instructions. Both McCall’s options list English and Spanish. If a particular language is important to the person sewing, this detail can decide between otherwise similar child patterns. Simplicity and the girls’ McCall’s pattern share the same broad child size span, but they differ in costume choice and language availability.
The women’s McCall’s pattern has the same listed language pair as the girls’ version, with the adult size range as its main distinction. Check that the language support matches the sewist who will follow the instructions; a pattern that suits the wearer but is difficult for the maker to follow is a poor project fit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are any of these products sewing machines?
No. All three products are paper sewing patterns that provide costume templates and instructions. They do not include a sewing machine. If you are searching for a machine to sew a Halloween costume, these listings do not answer that part of the search; they can help choose a costume project once you have access to a suitable machine and supplies.
Which pattern offers the most costume designs?
Simplicity 8726 includes five designs: bat man, witch, clown, vampire, and cat. Each McCall’s M6817 pattern includes two looks, a Scottish princess and a gothic vampire. I’d choose Simplicity when variety is the priority, and either McCall’s version when that particular pair of themes is the goal.
Which option is best for an adult Halloween costume?
The women’s McCall’s M6817 is the only adult-size option here, covering Small through Extra Large. The girls’ McCall’s pattern and Simplicity 8726 are listed for children’s sizes 3–8. Check the women’s pattern sizing guide against the intended wearer before buying or cutting fabric.
Are these patterns suitable for a first sewing project?
They are not presented as beginner-first patterns. Both McCall’s listings state average or above-average skill, and the supplied information for Simplicity does not identify it as an easier beginner option. A new sewist may still take on a project with help and enough time, but should not assume that costume sewing will be simple just because the item is sold as a Halloween pattern.
Do the patterns include fabric and sewing supplies?
The supplied product details describe paper patterns with templates and instructions, not complete costume kits. Simplicity’s listing explicitly says fabric and supplies must be purchased separately, and the McCall’s descriptions do not list fabric or other sewing supplies as included. Plan for those materials separately and check the packet details for any project-specific requirements.
Conclusion
For families who want the most costume choice for a child, I recommend Simplicity 8726: its five designs and three listed instruction languages make it the most flexible pick in this comparison. For a girl who specifically wants a Scottish-princess or gothic-vampire look, I’d choose the children’s McCall’s M6817 instead. Adults with the same theme should select the women’s M6817, since it is the only option here with adult sizing.
My final buying check would be the wearer’s measurements, the sewist’s comfort with average-or-higher skill work, and the separate materials needed to finish the project. These are costume patterns, not sewing machines; choose one for its fit and design, then plan the sewing equipment and supplies as a separate purchase.
